The Hell Months of summer are again upon us and it's too damn hot to think or post on weighty things, so it must be time for the annual posting of the recipe for ACD's Supernal Egg Salad.
What's that I hear y'all saying? We don't need no steeenkin recipe for egg salad? A trained chimp could make an egg salad without a recipe? Hard-boil the eggs. Cool the eggs. Shell the eggs. Chop the eggs. Throw in some mayonnaise. Mix with the eggs. Voila! Egg salad.
Uh-huh. Egg salad fit strictly for the proles. Here's an egg salad fit for the gods. Follow these instructions to the letter, and you'll end up with a thick, creamy, wonderfully flavorsome egg salad that's amazingly fluffy-light on tongue and palate. Shortcut the instructions, and you'll end up with an egg salad fit only for the aforementioned proles — or your cat.
And as you read, keep in mind, boys and girls: it's all in the technique.
What You Need (Ingredients)
(6) fairly fresh large eggs (boiling time is for this egg size)
(4-5) tblsps whole-egg mayonnaise (Hellmann's is fine; Miracle Whip is not)
(1) tsp smooth, for-real Dijon mustard (Grey Poupon is fine)
(1) smidge Lea & Perrins Worcestershire Sauce (no substitutes)
Salt
Black pepper, freshly ground
What You Need (Equipment)
(3) large bowls (the spun stainless steel type are best)
A fairly fine kitchen sieve (critical!).
An egg-slicer (not mandatory, but it makes the work go easier)
What You Do
Chill bowls in refrigerator.
Prepare the room-termperature eggs by setting them in the egg carton, pointy side down (that's the way they should come from the store). Using a safety pin, pierce the broad end of the egg. This insures that the gases that form while boiling escape, and therefore won't discolor the yolks with that yucky gray-green color around the edges, or build up that disgusting sulfur taste within the egg.
Fill a large pot (a pot large enough that the eggs won't be crowded when cooking) with enough water to comfortably cover the eggs even after the cooking is done. Cover, and bring water to full rolling boil. Quickly and gently transfer eggs to the boiling water. Cover pot, and very gently boil eggs for exactly 11 minutes. You don’t want the water boiling furiously. You'll have to lower the fire some after the water and eggs again come to a full boil (about 1 minute).
(Note: The eggs will not crack from the instant temperature change between room temperature and boiling water. If an egg does crack, it's because of a fault in the shell. Sometimes you can see the fault in advance; other times not. If an egg does crack, and the crack is small, you should be OK. If the crack is large, best to discard the offending egg.)
When eggs are about finished, take one of the chilled bowls from the fridge, and dump in a full tray of ice cubes. Fill with enough cold water to comfortably cover eggs. When eggs are done, turn off fire, quickly remove eggs from the hot water and lightly throw them into the iced water. This slightly cracks the shells, and insures quicker cooling to instantly stop the eggs from cooking once they're removed from the hot water. Place bowl with eggs and iced water into the refrigerator, and chill for at least 15 minutes. (Note: If you have a source of very cold running water, forget the ice and chill the eggs in the bowl with running cold water for at least 10 minutes.)
After eggs are fully chilled, place the bowl in the sink, and remove the shells from the eggs by banging the ends and then the sides of each egg all around against a flat, hard surface (the inside of the sink is handy and ideal). The shells will come off in a jiffy and very cleanly. Drop each shelled egg back into the iced water while you're removing the shells from the rest of the eggs.
Remove remaining two bowls from the refrigerator. Place sieve across one of the bowls. Then, one egg at a time, dry the egg, slice it, and separate yolk and white with the yolk going into the sieve, and the white into the other bowl. When all 6 eggs are sliced and separated, place bowl with whites back into the refrigerator.
With the back of a tablespoon, force yolks through the sieve into the bowl. This is the critical step, and the step most responsible for the fluffy texture and velvety mouth-feel of the finished salad. No, I've no idea why that makes the difference, but it does, my ignorance of the science behind it notwithstanding. Make sure to scrape into the bowl when you're done all the yolk that will adhere copiously to the outside of the sieve.
Add to the sieved yolks salt and pepper (careful with this; more salt and pepper will be added later). Then, in a separate small deep dish, mix one tblsp of the mayonnaise, Dijon mustard, and the smidge of L&P. Mix well, and add to the yolks. (Be very careful with the L&P. Just a smidge — about 1/8 tsp, I'm guessing — as it's very strong and will easily overwhelm the eggs and discolor the finished salad as well if too much is added.)
Then, mix the whole caboodle together using a fork, adding, a little at a time if necessary, more mayonnaise until the yolks finally reach a stiff, hold-together consistency. When finished, remove bowl with whites from refrigerator, and put bowl with yolks into the refrigerator.
Coarsely chop the whites. If you chop the whites too fine they'll "mush" together in the finished salad, and give it the wrong texture and the wrong taste (believe it or not). A large, very sharp chef's knife is the best tool to use for this step.
Remove yolk mixture from refrigerator, and dump the whites into the yolk mixture. Salt and pepper to taste. Add one tblsp of mayonnaise, then, gently and carefully begin folding whites, yolk mixture and mayonnaise together using one of those silicon or rubber pastry spatulas (if you're careless here, you'll end up "mushing" the whites), adding, a little at a time, more mayonnaise as needed to achieve a creamy, thick consistency. The consistency is correct when the salad just balls together, and leaves the sides of the bowl clean as you're mixing. If you add too much mayonnaise at this point you'll end up with a "watery" egg salad, and you don't want that. (The amount of mayonnaise can really fool you. When the mixture reaches the critical point, just an extra teaspoon or two more mayonnaise will ruin the whole salad.) Chill salad for at least one hour (more is better) before eating.
That's it. A supernal egg salad your palate will not soon forget.
Happy Hell Months, all. Or as happy as you can manage given the season.